Luke 13:1-9 March 23, 2025, Lent 3
We’re obviously missing
part of this conversation.
We
don’t really know anything about these
“Galileans whose blood
Pilate had mingled with their sacrifices.”
that they were telling
Jesus about. Then Jesus tells
the people talking to him
that they should repent
they will perish in the same way.
![]() |
Parable of the Fig Tree Paul Oman |
Then he gives a story about a
fig tree which seems like it’s
almost unrelated to everything else.
But it’s not.
So it seems that some Galileans, who would be Jewish,
were killed by Pilate – we
know historically that Pilate
was a cruel and violent leader,
and it was very common
for him to kill Jewish
people, and really all kinds of people,
just to make an example of
them for other people
who might step out of line.
And the Romans killed people as punishment all the
time then.
But these killings were worse. Either the Galileans were
killed in the temple where the sacrifices were done,
or
they were killed and then their blood was put on the altar after the sacrifice.
So their punishment was death, which was bad enough,
but it was also public
humiliation, religious insult,
and an insult to their
families and heritage,
which was worse even than
just death.
So the conversation was probably like this:
if these people were killed in such a horrible way
and their families were so insulted,
then they had to have been
terrible sinners
in order for God to
punish them in that way.
What could they have done
that was so bad?
And that was pretty much
how people understood things then.
God
was in control of all these situations.
It
wasn’t that Pilate was a demented despot who seemed
to
have a contest with himself about how cruel he could be.
It was God who caused it, and why would God cause that?
Unless
someone or their family had done something terrible.
This
was the prevailing theology of the time.
God
is an angry and vengeful God
and
the events of this world – natural or human –
are
just signs of God’s will.
You can see it in various
stories in the Old Testament scriptures
You
can see it in the story of Job and his friends.
They
insisted since Job had such misfortune
that
he obviously did something to upset God.
It’s a stubborn element in
our understanding of God
and
our relationship with God.
It
has prevailed in the Christian church throughout its existence.
And
some people still subscribe to it now.
The TV preacher, Pat
Robertson used to do it with every disaster.
He
said that the earthquake in Haiti was because
Haitians
worshipped the devil.
He said that Katrina was caused by the people in
New Orleans of supporting vices. And
he said that 9-11 happened
because
New York supported feminism.
It’s
not the earth is moving, it’s not climate change,
it’s
not even terrorism, it’s because God is mad
about
a selection of things that Pat Robertson didn’t like.
And just so you know it’s not just Pat Robertson,
The
Patriarch of the Russian Orthodox church,
said
after the Russians invaded Ukraine
that
that the Ukrainians were to blame for the invasion because
they
adopted too many western ways and had
a
gay pride parade. War was not the responsibility
of
an aggressive neighboring government,
it
was God’s judgement.
Even if we don’t go to the
extent this does,
we
still have that way of thinking in other ways.
We often do it to
ourselves,
When
illness or calamity hits us, we wonder
“What
have I done to deserve this?”
And then we look at other
people’s misfortune too
And
then we say things like
“There
but for the Grace of God go I.”
And
“I thank God for my blessings”
It still gets us to the
same place
Those
who are doing well are blessed by God.
Those
who are not doing well are cursed by God
Same
conclusion as those people
talking
about the Galileans with Jesus.
The trouble with this
understanding is
It
leads to some horrible conclusions
that
just don’t work with other parts of Christianity.
What
about the poor? what about people who are starving?
What
about the sick? What about those who have accidents and
just
plain misfortunes? Are every one of them horrible sinners?
What
about countries who have undergone horrible
genocides
and massacres?
Are
each one of those people to blame in some way?
Has
God punished every one of them?
And in doing this we paint
a really horrible portrait of God.
A God who is angry and punitive, who never forgets
or forgives.
A
God who keeps and excel spread sheet of our every fault and sin
and then waits to get revenge and who then metes out punishment
in the cruelest
ways and causes all the world’s suffering and pain.
A
picture of a God who is basically no better than Pilate.
A
God who kills and humiliates just to set an example.
I know that some people
really prefer this
picture of God, the one who takes revenge.
Who hates whoever they hate.
Who judges and enacts punishment.
But that’s not the God I’ve read about in scripture.
God is loving and forgiving,
slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love.
Even in the Hebrew Scriptures.
And certainly not the God that I learned about
from Jesus.
And that’s what is in the
background of this
conversation that Jesus is having with these other
people.
They were talking about this horrible punishment
these other people endured and the question was
“what did they do so bad that they God would
punish them and humiliate them so bad?”
They didn’t ask why Pilate was so crazy
Just why God was so angry with them.
And Jesus doesn’t try to
talk them out of it.
But
he makes them part of the equation.
Jesus says to them, basically,
If
you want to play that game theologically and
drag
God into it, and judge the victims we can play.
But
realize you’re going to lose too.
If you want to look into
the heart of God,
and
try to see who’s got the upper hand or the better grade,
then
know that you’re just as much of a disappointment.
If Pat Robertson and
Patriarch Kirill
want
to subscribe to the picture of God who is
counting
all our sins and tallying up the debts we owe,
Then
honestly, they will be judged more than all
the
people they’re judging. In fact, we’re all done for.
Then Jesus says in essence,
“Now that you know you’re in the same boat
as the people you judge.
Let me give you another picture of God
the way that that I understand God.”
There’s a vineyard and a
tree in it.
And
the tree is not bearing fruit
It’s
a fig tree, and its whole purpose
is
to give figs but it’s not doing it.
And the landowner wants it
gone
and
maybe by rights that is what should happen.
But
that Gardener is too soft hearted.
The
gardener says, just give it one more year.
Just
give it one more year.
The landowner is those
judgmental people.
The
ones who love punishment and rules.
The
people who run by the way of the world.
The
ones who have no time for God’s mercy and forgiveness.
They
want to cut the trees down and throw them out.
And we are those trees,
we
are made in the image of God
but
we are not reflecting God to others.
We’re
not doing what we were meant to do.
Not
caring and serving. We’re not carrying our own crosses
and
following Christ’s way of love and sacrifice.
We
are not giving fruit.
And the Gardner is God.
That
gardener knows how to create and cultivate
And
that’s what he wants to do with
the
trees who don’t bear fruit.
The Gardener knows that the right amount
of water, food, and care, can do things.
But
it takes time. He wants to nurture us to life.
Look, God wants us to
change. God needs this world to change.
Something is definitely going off the rails in this
world,
and we are all part of it. It’s not just the fault
of one
political party, or one person, or one government.
It’s all of us. God needs us all to repent and
change.
God
needs us to turn from the ways of death to the ways of life.
But God will not do it by cutting us down
and
throwing us out, even though we might deserve it.
God
has decided not to punish, but to love us into life.
Maybe that gardener is
just a silly optimist.
But
that’s the kind of gardener he is.
In
his career, he has seen plenty of trees that were left for dead
come
back later and bear lots of fruit.
So
every year that gardener says, “just one more year.”
“Let’s
give that tree just one more year.”
This is God that Jesus
knows and reveals to us.
That
is the image that Jesus offers those people.
And
one that they can offer to the world.
Jesus reveals a God who
knows that fear of punishment
can
make people obedient,
but
that love can make them alive again.
It might take longer, it
might be more work.
It
might not be the most expedient way.
But
Jesus tells us, that the God that he knows,
has
chosen to love and forgive us back into life.