Matthew 21:23-32
September 27, 2026
![]() |
| Jesus Preaching to the Multitude Jorge Coco Santangelo |
I’m going to tell you something you
may
or may not know about Lutherans – or more
specifically Lutheran seminary professors –
when it comes to our basic tenant of Lutheranism.
Justification by God’s grace, not by
our works.
We love it. (That’s not the insider info by the way.)
We believe it. It converted me,
I think Luther was right about stressing it completely
considering where Christianity was at the time.
We are saved by God’s grace and not by what we do.
Here I stand I can do no other.
But the insider info is that
professors of Lutheranism
and therefore Lutheran pastors,
are really leery about putting a definite
picture together about what you do AFTER
you know you’ve been saved.
Don’t worry, I’ll over-explain this
for you.
Here’s how the fourth article of the Augsburg Confession
reads:
“Human beings cannot be justified
before God by their own powers, merits, or works. But they are justified as a
gift on account of Christ through faith when they believe that they received
into grace and that their sins are forgiven on account of Christ, who by his
death made satisfaction for our sins.
God reckons this faith as
righteousness.”
So it’s kind of circular logic, MC
Escher drawing:
we are saved by Christ when we believe that we’re saved
by Christ.
Our faith in our salvation becomes our righteousness.
So all talk about sin, and our actions
and the beatitudes and anything Jesus said
is just there to help us to realize how sinful we are,
and how we deserve to be eternally punished for our sins,
and that realization drives us to ask for mercy,
and we find that in the belief
that Christ died for us for our sins.
Our Faith is becomes the righteous robe which
covers our wardrobe of sinfulness.
Therefore faith is our ultimate goal.
BUT Lutherans, Lutheran professors,
and Lutheran pastors,
and Luther are/were reticent, hesitant, resistant
to talking about what people of faith
then are supposed to do AFTER they have faith.
In the Lutheran Theological world
They call that, “the third use of the law”
and it’s usually said with a wrinkled nose
like you’ve smell something funny.
Our professor in Philadelphia did have
one class called
“What we do after we know we don’t have to do anything”
but other professors I know kind of cut off
the conversation about it entirely.
One pastor said that their professors at a more uber-Lutheran
seminary said
“your questions about this are not helpful”.
I’ve had my conversation about it cut off at times.
The Lutheran ideal is that, because you’re
thankful for God’s grace, the good works of Jesus
will flow out of you naturally, whatever comes out of
your
thankfulness for your salvation must be good.
(Isn’t everything that all Christians do good?)
Lutherans are kind of stuck on salvation.
All Protestantism, American Protestantism at least,
seems to be stuck on salvation.
The objective is to confess Jesus Christ as
your personal Lord and Savior and once you’ve done that,
then your only objective is to get other people
to confess Jesus Christ as their personal Lord and
Savior.
And there’s a lingering feeling in Christianity
that if we get enough people doing that,
even if that’s by force or coercion,
then all will be right with the world.
The objective with a lot of
Even the creeds that we say each week.
The ones which have guided the Christian
church since the fourth century,
are all about what we believe together
about God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit.
I believe in God, We believe in Jesus Christ.
Christianity is like a club you get
into
and once you’re in we’re all good.
And I think that this feeling,
attitude,
deeply held theological premise,
whatever you call it, has left a large, nebulous void.
The objective is to convert,
declare your Christianity, then people can just
fill in what want into that blank outline that is
Christianity.
I know that there are many different
ways
to live out our faith and everyone has different
gifts that God can use in many ways to serve the gospel.
But everything that every Christian who believes
that Jesus saved them has not been good.
There have been some very faithful Christians
who have done some very lousy things.
I mean, we have Christians right now who
are
making laws and policies that immigrants who don’t
have citizenship should be put into concentration camps.
Who are taking healthcare from needy people.
We have Christians who feel comfortable saying every kind of
cruel and hateful thing about poor people.
Who believe that think blatant racism is a trait of a
Christian.
Who are right now, defending slavery.
Lutherans are some of those people too.
Because of the void, people have
filled
that blank slate in with whatever their impulses lead
them.
Making faith the ultimate mark of discipleship
has put Christianity in some murky places over the years.
Wouldn’t it have been helpful if we had
some guidance?
Could it have been helpful if we in addition to the
normal
creeds, we had spent 2000 years saying every week:
“we treat every human as a child of
God.
We won’t be racist, sexist, and
classist oafs.
We will love our enemies.
We make sacrificial service to others
a priority”
I know I’m giving my Lutheran
professors a brain
aneurism at this point, but couldn’t that have been
helpful?
I always remind everyone that the
earliest Christians
called their religion “the Way”.
You followed the Way of Jesus.
It was about living the way that Jesus did
and doing the things that he told them to do.
And I’m going to go out on a limb and say that
even people who don’t believe in Jesus as
their Lord and Savior can follow “the way of Jesus”.
It’s not about believing in a doctrine,
it’s about following the way.
And Jesus stresses that in the gospel
today.
(remember we have a gospel to talk about?)
Jesus tells this really simple parable.
This parable only shows up in Matthew by the way.
The parable is about two sons.
Father asks them to
do something.
One said yes and didn’t do what he was supposed to.
One said no, and did it any way.
The question is: Who did the will of his father.
Of course the second one.
Jesus is saying that the chief priests and the Elders
are like the first son who just paid lip service to God.
And the Tax collectors and prostitutes are like the second son
who are actually doing God’s will.
Jesus is saying that what we do
actually
matters to God. It’s not just a litmus test.
It’s not just an abstract hypothetical paradigm.
And the tax collectors and prostitutes were doing
a better job of the whole thing than the religious
leaders.
Something relevant about tax
collectors and prostitutes
Mark Allen Powell, who was the New Testament
prof at Trinity Seminary in Ohio when I was
serving in Ohio was sharing this amazing
research he was doing on tax collectors
and prostitutes (or “sinners” as earlier translations
of the bible calls them wrongly because I guess
they didn’t want to give any delicate people the vapors.)
We all know how much Jesus talked
about tax
collectors and prostitutes and how much
scorn he received because he was
eating with them and hanging out with them in public.
thieves basically, and our classic view of
prostitutes is overly sexual women.
Mark Allen Powell says that neither
were correct
Both of them were most likely people
that were sold into slavery at young ages.
When families couldn’t pay off debts,
it was common to sell their children off
permanently into slavery.
Tax collectors were most likely big
strong boys
who probably had some mental challenges.
They were enslaved to threaten people and
forcibly extract money from people
for the Roman government.
And prostitutes were young women
who were sold and trafficked into sex work.
Powell says that in historical writings
from the time, there are very few
adult women talked about as prostitutes
the cut off age was 15 or 16 because the
truth was, very few of the girls sold into
sex slavery survived into adulthood.
Tax collectors and prostitutes were
not
degenerates who chose an easy life of
fun and debauchery. They were people
who had all their personal agency and humanity
taken away from them at a young age to
fulfill the endless greed that is human society.
And Mark Allen Powell notes that by this point in Jesus ministry,
Jesus had actually stopped telling tax collectors
and prostitutes that they needed to repent
to prepare for the kingdom of God.
their professions since they were slaves.
They would be beaten or killed if they did.
But they could live the life that they were forced in
differently.
They could still follow the way of Jesus.
Tax collectors and prostitutes were
obviously
looked down on, (much like prostitutes are now even though
most of them have been also, been trafficked at young ages.)
And the religious leaders and most of the rest of the
people
would have thought themselves superior to them.
But it’s obvious from this this
parable
and how Jesus uses them as his lesson to the religious
leaders,
that after they joined Jesus at his table and followed
his way. Meaning they did their life differently.
They couldn’t change their status or jobs,
but within their present lives, they did God’s will.
Maybe they treated others with
kindness,
Maybe they sacrificed for others,
or shared with others or they regarded others with
respect,
they tried to love their enemies and not hurt them.
And Jesus elevates these people
who were normally looked down on.
Jesus is telling those religious leaders:
“You should work your way up to level of these people.
Make their behavior your goal.”
Don’t change your profession either, but look
at the way they are conducting themselves now
be like them instead of how you’re being now.
That is doing the will of God.
Whatever these despised groups of followers
were doing was closer to God’s hopes for humanity
than what the religious leaders were doing.
Notice that Jesus says that the tax
collectors
and prostitutes are getting in to the Kingdom of God
first.
Meaning that the Chief priests and the elders
are still recipients of God’s grace,
they just may have to wait in line.
So Jesus is obviously a good Lutheran.
Luther was reported to have said this:
“God does not need your good works, but your neighbor
does”
That kind of thinking was effective to stress
justification by God’s grace which was Luther’s job.
But I really think now, we can say God
does need
our good works. And those works need to
be based on Jesus words and commands and
Jesus actions. At this time especially,
God need us not to not just to
say that Jesus is our Lord and savior,
but to live that out in our world.
God needs us to do those things
that Jesus outlined and modeled for us
over and over again in his life.
God needs us to help save the world.
I think that is good news.
God’s not asking us to do it alone,
God’s certainly going to do some heavy lifting,
but for some reason, God wants to work with us.
And with the tax collectors and prostitutes
and all the other outcast people in our world.
And us religious leaders can even come along too.

No comments:
Post a Comment